When developing games for Windows 8 with C# it is not immediately clear how to construct a basic game loop. For other Microsoft platforms XNA is the obvious choice. However because Microsoft does not support XNA in Windows 8, developers are left to their own resources. After developing several games for Windows 8 I have compiled my experiences on the various ways to implement a game loop for Windows 8 and C#. I invite you to read on and decide which one best suits your needs.

If you decide to write a game using C# and XAML you may think to use a DispatcherTimer to construct your game loop. While this works, in practice I have found its performance to be unusable for games. Instead I have found three alternatives which provide adequate performance without relying on the DispatcherTimer. Which one is right for you depends on your situation. At a high level the options are:

XNA and MonoGame CompositionTarget Rendering MonoGame's GameTimer
External Dependency Yes No No
Fixed Time Step Yes No Yes
Variable Time Step Yes Yes Yes

Rely on MonoGame

If you already have a game based on XNA, are willing to take on a big dependency, or are creating a 3D game then using MonoGame to handle your game loop is likely your best choice. On the other hand, if you're developing a 2D game and plan to have lots of user interface elements adopting MonoGame may be overkill. Ultimately, you will have to decide whether you want to take on a big external dependency and shape your code to fit into XNA's framework.

CompositionTarget.Rendering

If you are unfamiliar with XNA, want to create more complex user interfaces, want to more easily support different screen resolutions, or just want to avoid an extra dependency then your next option is to add an event handler for the global static event CompositionTarget.Rendering. This event fires once per each frame. The advantage of this approach is it is very easy to implement. Simply add the event handler and be on your way. That being said, there is no way to know how much time has passed between frames meaning your game's updates will be linked to the frame rate. For many games this is not acceptable.

Cherry Pick MonoGame's GameTimer

Your game may not require XNA but you may need to know how much time has elapsed between frames. As a result the first two options do not work for you game. Fortunately, it's possible to combine the best of both approaches.

You may be wondering how MonoGame supports a fixed time step in Windows 8. The magic takes place in the GameTimer class. If you take a look you’ll see that GameTimer also listens for the CompsotionTarget.Rendering event and uses a Stopwatch to keep track of the time between events.

Fortunately, MonoGame is an open source project licensed under the Microsoft Public License. As a result you can simply take the GameTimer class and add it to your project. This way you can develop a game with fixed or variable time steps without adding an external dependency.

Wrapping Up

Ultimately which option is best depends on your circumstances. If you plan to use XNA then using MonoGame is a no-brainer. If not then I would recommend using MonoGame's GameTimer. In any case, you now have the knowledge to make an informed decision. Best of luck developing your Windows 8 game!

Continue reading my series on making games for Windows 8:

If you've read this far, share the article and sign up for updates!